2017 in retrospect: the 50 best amvs (20 – 11)

20. LittleAtari – Insomnia

Anime: Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children
Song: “Beautiful” by Eminem

Advent Children AMVs are a rare sight these days, but if you were around the AMV scene ten years ago you certainly wouldn’t have felt that way; I’ve touched on this before, but it bears repeating that AC was an extremely overused source, and literally everything was done with it. LittleAtari’s release this year doesn’t do anything particularly new — there are several decent rap videos out there that use Advent Children as a source, but this is a worthy addition to any collection. It does especially well at highlighting Cloud’s emo personality, painting him as the misunderstood loner that Eminem raps as. It’s always risky when editors take a song that fits a character’s most exaggerated qualities and focus in on those — it’s too easy to make the characters into caricatures, and in drama videos like this, that can be a bad thing. But LittleAtari deftly navigates his way through these pitfalls and comes out the other end with a deeply resonant character profile, and maybe the best Advent Children video released this decade.

19. EnQuatre – Combat Harness

Anime: Mobile Suit Gundam Thunderbolt: December Sky
Song: “Can You Hold Me” by NF

I don’t know if, in my 11 years now of avidly consuming AMVs, I have ever seen a video go from 0 to 60 as quickly as this one does. The first time I watched it I had mentally checked out about a minute in, and was prepared to suffer through the rest just to say I finished it, when the video ramped up to such intensity that I was left wondering if my computer had spontaneously switched to another video halfway through. It’s an absolutely riveting video, with a phenomenal story and emotional energy spilling over the brim. With this release EnQuatre has created a laser-focused, tightly executed stream of overpowering drama, and one of the most adrenaline-pumping videos released all year.

18. seasons – Leeway

Anime: Pilot Candidate (Candidate For Goddess)
Song: “To Rococo Rot” by Die Dinge Des Lebens

If introversion were a quality that an editor could translate to his AMVs, I feel like the result would be something close to Leeway. This is a very abstract video in that there’s no narrative or attempt at a tangible concept. It feels very personal, and I think that no one will experience this one quite the same — although I thoroughly enjoy this video (which should be obvious based on where I’m putting it on my list), I’m fairly certain that what I get out of it is probably very different than what seasons gets out of it when he watches it, or what you will when you watch it.

As far as the actual content goes, this video moves very slowly, threading completely (or at least, seemingly) unrelated scenes together to create a mood-heavy canvas of slow-moving visuals whose entire purpose is to allow you to project onto them. The scenes are often heavily blurred at first, and weirdly the video’s prevalent banding (normally an undesirable video quality issue) creates these surreal, morphing shapes that are impossible to guess at until the focus is restored. It all adds to the mystique and often impenetrable nature of the video.

Leeway is quite unlike anything else I watched this year. It summons nostalgia out of thin air, for nothing in particular, and leaves behind this aching sense of some unknown memory. It defies a clear description, leading me to do a bunch of esoteric rambling that probably sounds pretty heavy-handed and pretentious. But that’s what I love about it — it doesn’t fit neatly into any single category, and no adjectives seem to do it justice. After everything I’ve said, it still feels like a woefully incomplete explanation of what it’s like to watch this thing. So, you know, watch it and figure it out your own darn self!

17. Pysh – Sunny Day

Anime: Various
Song: “Kokyou” by Yasuharu Takanashi

As I’m sitting here writing this, my phone says it’s 1°F outside, on a December evening. I let my car run for about 15 minutes this morning before I got in it to go to work, and it was still cold. Stepping outside is pretty much the worst thing in the world right now, but Sunny Day is possibly the best remedy yet for the winter chill — it’s a bright, warm, cozy little video that features clip after sunny clip of summer scenery and calm, nostalgic settings. It’s a lot like my favorite video of last year in the sense that there’s no story, just a straightforward concept, edited simply (nothing but hard cuts in this one) in order to convey a very relatable feeling. Videos like this often strike at the heart of what it is I tend to love about AMVs in as accessible way as it’s possible to do — creating imagery that conjures up feelings I want to feel. There’s not really more that needs to be said than that.

16. Megamom – Belleza

Anime: Re:Zero – Starting Life In Another World
Song: “Belleza” by Fármacos

Every year there are at least a few videos that are released that go criminally unrecognized (okay, more than just a few). Megamom’s videos always seem to fall into this camp, and it’s a shame, because if anyone deserves the spotlight for making stuff that is consistently creative, beautiful, and unlike anything else, it’s him. Belleza is definitely a “Megamom” video in every way — the music choice, the color schemes, the narrative approach that is vague but tantalizingly substantial; I feel like the more I watch this video, the more I can unpack its meaning and chronology, even without ever having watched Re:Zero. Megamom loves to hide meaning and emotion in his videos in such a way that it’s impossible to take it all in at once, and he does a whole lot of that here. This is a video that begs to be replayed again and again until every crevice has been searched and learned by heart.

There are moments of pure aesthetic beauty, as well — the scenes of sped-up clouds, of flowers unfolding (and then folding back up when the scenes are reversed), of clocks in clocks in clocks…it makes for a stunningly gorgeous and (dare I say it) artsy AMV, even if you choose to ignore the story the editor is trying to tell. Belleza continues Megamom’s tradition of looking at things from some hidden angle known only to him, where he’s able to see his sources in a light that reveals shadows and textures that are invisible to the rest of us. I wish I could get inside his head.

15. numbuh0051 – Can’t Stop The Anime!

Anime: Various
Song: “Can’t Stop The Feeling” by Justin Timberlake

I’m pretty sure I’ve said this before, but truly good dance AMVs are hard to come by; although many videos categorize themselves as “dance”, few actually live up to the name, so when I see one that actually fulfills the requirements (i.e. it makes me want to get up and fricking MOVE), I take notice. Can’t Stop The Anime! is the first such video I’ve seen in quite a while, but the wait has been absolutely worth it — it creeped up out of nowhere, winning Best Local Video at this year’s NDK contest, created by an editor who, at the time, had a whole two videos to her name.

The video is a spirited compilation of dance scenes from a wide range of anime, edited with a keen sense of motion and rhythm. Internal sync pops up in unexpected places and the video never loses its spark, moving from one high-energy scene to the next at a constant clip. It’s brimming with positivity and a love of life, and one gets the sense that however random the anime selection may seem, the editor truly loves each and every one of the sources she’s using. For the few ways here and there that I could level a criticism or suggestion for improvement, there are way more instances of purely exhilarating editing, and one thing I can’t fault the editor for is for making something driven by a sense of excitement and sheer joy. It shows in every nook and cranny of this video, full of vigor and love of the craft. Let this one take over — get outta your seat and DANCE!

14. Copycat_Revolver – 2006 AD

Anime: Iria: Zeiram The Animation
Song: “Rogues” by Incubus

The video’s title, according to Copycat_Revolver, is a reference to the year when he originally had the idea for this video. While it’s sad that it took 11 years to finally get it out, this is a problem every editor who’s been around for a long enough time will experience — having a backlog of ideas that never materialize, possibly ever. I have plenty, and every year I tell myself, “This is the year”, and it never is, so I relate to this video in a very specific way that has nothing to do with its actual content. Hopefully it’ll motivate me to reach into the vault to get some of these out on the timeline this year, but that remains to be seen.

As it stands, 2006 AD is just a solid action video, through and through, with an old-school feel that ties everything together in Copycat’s typically capable style. It’s worth mentioning that I’ve never even heard of this series before or seen it used in any AMVs (that I’m aware of, anyway), but watching the video has convinced me that “Rogues” was probably written by Incubus so that one day Copycat_Revolver would stumble across both and smash them together just like this (and, perhaps unsurprisingly, this isn’t the first time I’ve felt that about one of his videos). This video contains such intoxicating synergy, in ways that go beyond the editing choices. The anime looks like what Incubus sounds like, and credit where it’s due — Copycat_Revolver discovered the combination and made it work.

13. Nellogs – The Piano That Transforms Into a Time Traveling DeLorean

Anime: Neon Genesis Evangelion (remakes)
Song: “Year 3000” by The Jonas Brothers

It’s rare that a video’s title so accurately captures exactly what the video is, especially one as ridiculously-named as this one, but…well, here we are. It’s a silly concept (and a pretty dumb song, if I’m being honest), but Nellogs worked some serious magic here, or sacrificed a virgin to a pagan god or something, and came out with an incredibly unique video, something that I would have never been able to dream up in a million years. It’s pure fun, driven by excellent lyric sync and rhythmic editing, using an anime that is so far removed from working with this type of music that only a very talented hand could avert it from becoming a flaming disaster. Seriously, when Nellogs is on his game he makes crack AMVs — the kind of stuff that you will never want to leave your hard drive. Don’t let this one slip through.

12. Elcalavero – Journey To Find A Name

Anime: Angel’s Egg
Song: “Take Three” by Jerry Folk

Elcalavero is a distinct anomaly in the AMV world. His videos are completely outside of what I would consider any kind of “mainstream” style, focusing less on what many people might consider fundamentals and more on less tangible elements, like atmosphere. Until this year I’d always enjoyed his videos from a distance, but something clicked with his releases this time around that made them more personal to me. His work is always dark, foreboding; almost horror but with enough faint light at the edges to keep the monsters at bay. Journey To Find A Name finds itself comfortably inside this framework, but the editing is just slightly more tightly wound than in Elcalavero’s previous videos — it’s less slippery, there’s finally something solid to grasp onto.

But only just. There’s little character development, little context, lots of shots of scenery and crumbling stonework and bones. Elcalavero seems much more interested in exploring the world in Angel’s Egg than he is of scrutinizing the subject of the video’s title, but that’s not a criticism. The resultant video is one of deep, despondent atmosphere and a mood that would be hard to communicate in any other way. This is the kind of stuff that no one is making that I wish there was more of — and if anyone is going to lead that charge, it’s going to be this guy.

11. Radical_Yue – Nan Desu Kan 2017 AMV Contest Intro

Anime: Various
Song: “This Is Where It Starts” by Mark Prince

Welp, when I made my list last year I had ranked Yue’s 2016 NDK Contest Intro high on my list and asked her to make something as good this year…and I have to say, she absolutely delivered. Doused in sentimentality and with a whole lot of basically perfect internal sync, this is a high-energy feels trip the likes of which were matched by only a few other videos this year which we have yet to get to. There’s no story or concept in this one — it’s random scenes, often heavily emotional or action-oriented, but when so much heart is in a video, it’s easy to lose yourself in the imagery and just let it all wash over you. This video is successful no matter how you approach it — as an adrenaline-pumping opener to an AMV contest, as an example of phenomenal editing, or as a sentimental celebration of the medium. Radical_Yue is starting to set a precedent here, and it just makes me all that much more excited to see what precedes the AMV contest at next year’s NDK.


About crakthesky

Early 30s and vocal about my subculture.
This entry was posted in amv, retrospect and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to 2017 in retrospect: the 50 best amvs (20 – 11)

  1. Seasons says:

    I actually watched Insomnia very shortly after it was released, not sure where or why because this wasn’t an editor I was following and this is NOT a source that gets me in a rush to click on anything besides the back button in my browser. Somehow I forgot all about it (first of two AMVs like that in this section, probably more elsewhere), which is weird because I thoroughly, completely enjoyed this AMV. The lyrics AND tone of the song are a perfect match for the dreary visuals that somehow make yet another update on this story feel more justified than it ever should. Anyway, not only does the concept work from beginning to end, LittleAtari somehow found a way to edit a convincing action video to this slow slosh of a song in a way that shouldn’t be possible but, well, never feels anything less than completely natural. There’s even really good lip sync in this. This isn’t footage that you should be able to do that with at all! Maybe my biggest omission that I should have remembered, so I’m glad you didn’t forget it too.

    I HATED Combat Harness when I watched it in Pro. That’s a weird opinion, it’s a pretty good AMV, I just found it too slow and dark and serious for my tastes. I think having it fall into the final third of the playlist I was watching them all in certainly did it a disservice, as a mental, possibly physical fatigue for videos with this kind of tone had just overtaken me at that point and I was extremely eager to let out my frustrations on the least deserving offender in the whole category. EQ probably did the best job possible with this song and this anime (which I’ve never watched but feel like I have after so many AMVs have featured it in very similar ways). Technically this video is nothing short of beautiful, and I don’t think I can carry on pretending that it’s not everything that we all strive to make when we sit down to edit a drama AMV.

    Sunny Day…did nothing for me. I can see the appeal and I love the concept but there were many moments where it just felt a little too random to me, a couple shots that just felt out of place (just to pick out one, the six-second clip at 0:45 could definitely have been replaced by something that would have conveyed any feeling whatsoever). I love simple videos like this, just not this one.

    I keep sleeping on Megamom AMVs even though I love so, so much of his past work. Again, how I missed this, I’m not sure (I mean, I guess I know why and I’ll try not to let it happen again) and I really regret it because wow, this was really a beautiful AMV. This song is great! It sounds so big and bright and emotional and the video makes the most of all its cues and is more than up to the task of painting an equally vivid and fantastic world. We started watching this anime and dropped it after 6 or 7 episodes. Kind of thinking we should give it another chance now (for no good reason, I know, this AMV has no obligation to be an accurate depiction of it any more than a movie trailer is ever supposed to be “honest”). I was already 100% onboard with this video and where it was going BEFORE it even got to all the most beautiful sequences in the second half. I’m so happy this editor keeps making videos and sharing them with us. Why on earth does this have less than 300 views in six months? I could make similar complaints about a lot of videos on this list but this one in particular makes no sense to me at all.

    Can’t Stop The Anime has no big or unique ideas in it all and it’s edited in the most basic way I’ve ever seen someone make a video like this and it’s nothing less than totally awesome. This is technically better than anything I’ve ever made and will probably ever edit and it looks like this is only the third AMV this person has made. There probably wasn’t a better dance AMV than this in 2017, right? I remember when I used to hate this category because it wasn’t “AMVs that make you want to dance” or whatever nonsense I thought it was supposed to be instead of literally AMVs Featuring Dance Scenes, which couldn’t possibly be anything but different videos featuring the same 5 or 6 OP cuts edited in a different order again and again. How wrong I was.

    2006 AD, another video I already saw and forgot about, which makes no sense given how cool this is. I don’t like Incubus at all, but now I’ll probably think of this video every time I hear this song and that’s probably going to change my feelings about it.

    Nellogs’ Eva video is, again, another Eva AMV that I never could have conceived and that probably no one else could have brought into this world. It’s not my favorite Eva AMV from him either, but that’s asking a little too much. I have nothing to say about this but it’s good that it exists (how an unlisted video gets over 400 views is a mystery to me).

    Journey to Find a Name isn’t just a beautiful AMV that features a lot of cool shots, it’s edited just as smoothly as anything Elcalavero has ever done (and is probably his most technically sound effort so far). I didn’t give this the credit it deserves, the atmosphere he builds in this is unmatched.

    NDK Intro video is a Radical_Yue AMV, enough said I guess. This strikes me a terrible idea in practice because surely it made most of the videos in the contest that immediately followed look like garbage by comparison. But yeah, this would get people hyped up.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s